Major League Wage Theft: How Baseball Owners and Congress Exploit Minor League Players

Joel Mendelson

Joel Mendelson Communications Specialist, Jobs with Justice

Baseball season begins this week and fans across the country will see their favorite players and all-stars play in places like Yankee Stadium, Fenway Park, and Wrigley Field. The season commencement will also be cause for celebration for the former farm team players who advanced to the majors for the first time. By joining a major league team, an athlete finally earns a fair return on his work and performance.

As for the infielders, pitchers, shortstops and the rest of the players in the minors?  As a result of a recent act by federal lawmakers, they’re starting out the season with a losing streak. Thousands of professional athletes who play for the Albuquerque Isotopes, Montgomery Biscuits, Kannapolis Intimidators, and the nearly 250 teams in Minor League Baseball could soon make less than the minimum wage.

On Friday, Congress eliminated Fair Labor Standards Act (FLSA) protections for minor league players through a provision buried in the 2200-plus page omnibus spending bill. The “Save America’s Pastime Actreclassifies baseball players as “seasonal employees,” thus allowing wealthy owners to pay them for only regular season games. Now owners can technically avoid paying players for all their hours spent in spring training, off-season workouts, team meetings, appearances, and more.

Even though they are employed by the same Major League team owners, for every superstar like Giancarlo Stanton or Bryce Harper earning millions, there’s a career minor leaguer just trying to put food on the table for his family. Working and living conditions for minor leaguers are anything but glamorous. Those playing in the lower levels often struggle to make ends meet, earning as little as $1100 a month for only three months a year. That’s less than most people working at fast-food restaurants earn. Players often take second jobs during the offseason, while still trying to train, practice, and prepare for a shot at the big leagues.

Despite turning significant profits, every season the league refuses to pay minor leaguers sustainable wages. At the same time, billionaire owners ask for and typically receive huge subsidies of public taxpayer dollars to fund new stadiums.

In recent years, players filed multiple lawsuits against Major League Baseball, accusing the league of intentionally underpaying and exploiting minor league players. In 2017, a federal appeals court ruled against four players, who alleged Major League Baseball colluded to pay players low wages. They believed Major League Baseball violated antitrust laws. However, the Save America’s Pastime Act isn’t the first time Congress put MLB owners before players. In the late-1990s, Congress passed a bill exempting Major League Baseball from antitrust laws. The lawsuit alleging MLB withheld wages and exploited players violated the FLSA, remains active, but the new law could hamper players’ efforts to hold MLB and owners accountable.

Given the league’s extreme opposition to paying minor league players a sustainable wage, why do major league baseball players earn considerable sums and benefit from endorsement deals? For decades, owners controlled everything about players. In the late-1960s, players had enough. St. Louis Cardinals’ outfielder Curt Flood helped lead the first organizing effort and together with labor veteran Marvin Miller, players joined together and formed the Major League Baseball Players’ Association. Over the course of the next five decades, players fought to win their freedom to sign with different teams, negotiate strong contracts, and ensure owners could no longer exploit them or future players in the majors.

We call foul on the Major League Baseball, and billionaire team owners using their friends in Congress to rig the rules of the game. Once again, underhanded lawmakers rigged the rules to keep billionaires happy. In doing so, they stripped minor league players of their freedom to earn a decent wage training for and playing the game they love. As we all head to the ballpark this season, let’s remember that baseball players—like all working people—deserve a fair shake and the power in numbers to take care of their basic needs in life.


Reposted from JWJ

Posted In: Allied Approaches

Union Matters

In New York, the Art of a Deal Gone Bitterly Bad

Sam Pizzigati

Sam Pizzigati Editor, Too Much online magazine

“If you gain fame, power, or wealth,” the philosopher Philip Slater once noted, “you won’t have any trouble finding lovers, but they will be people who love fame, power, or wealth.” Tell me about it, David Mugrabi might be thinking right about now. The billionaire art dealer and his wife Libbie Mugrabi are currently contesting a bitter divorce that has the New York couple in and out of the courts and the headlines. In July, the two tussled in a tug-of-war over a $500,000 20-inch-tall Andy Warhol sculpture. Libbie claims the incident had her fearing for her life, and a friend has testified that David angrily called her and Libbie “low-lifes” and “gold-diggers.” The latest installment: Last Tuesday, lawyers argued over how much Libbie should get for a vacation she and their two kids will be taking this Thanksgiving. Libbie’s lawyer asked for an amount commensurate with the couple’s “$3.5-million-a-year lifestyle.” The judge okayed $4,000, then added: “No one’s going to starve in this family.”

More ...

A Pattern of Poverty

A Pattern of Poverty